Assessment · insurance brokers round insurance-brokers-2026-09

Compare HGV Insurance review

Ranked 9 of 10 in Insurance brokers in Telford

Best for: telford hauliers needing truck and fleet cover

Active

Trading as One Sure Insurance Limited · Telford · Service area: Telford

Compare HGV Insurance in short

Compare HGV Insurance is a Telford broker that only does haulage, covering tippers, mixers, skip lorries, refrigerated and livestock carriers plus goods in transit and excess cover. That narrow focus suits hauliers who want a broker speaking their trade, and the site names the people behind the truck, fleet, renewals and claims teams. Telford born-and-bred roots run through the site's telling of the story.

Customer reviews of Compare HGV Insurance are middling, at three point six out of five across fewer than twenty Google reviews. BIBA membership sits alongside stated FCA authorisation on the firm's own site. It counts against the firm that the review score trails the rest of the table, and no fees, commission terms or VAT position are published.

The firm works from Stafford Park in Telford as the trading name of a wider insurance operator. The operator record is active since the mid-noughties. Phone and contact-form routes sit on the site. One Sure Insurance stands behind the trading name.

The evidence base is small, and it stands out against an otherwise strong round for customer voices. That gap between trade focus and public testimony is the honest tension in this review. Our judgement is that the trade focus wins it for hauliers who want a broker speaking their trade, despite the numbers. That is our reading of a thin but genuine trade record.

Compare HGV Insurance reviews and ratings on other sites

Every public rating we hold for Compare HGV Insurance, with the source, scale, count and the date we read it. These are customers' ratings, not ours.
Source	Rating	Reviews	Read on
Google	3.6 out of 5	17	4 September 2026

Our verdict

Our judgement: Compare HGV suits you if you run trucks in or around Telford and want a broker that only does haulage. The product range is deep for the niche and BIBA membership is stated. It counts against it that the review score is middling and nothing about cost is published.

Score summary

Scored on the home trades rubric v2.0. Insufficient evidence takes the neutral value and is not shown as a low mark.

Composite score: 57.8 / 100

Customer evidence C1 · weight 30%

41 out of 100

Google 3.6 out of 5 from 17 reviews ^[5].

Qualifications and accreditations C2 · weight 25%

75 out of 100

Financial Conduct Authority authorisation is listed on the business's own website ^[2]. Membership of the British Insurance Brokers' Association is listed on the site ^[1].

First-hand responsiveness C3 · weight 15%

Insufficient evidence

Trading history C4 · weight 10%

80 out of 100

On the Companies House record since 2005 ^[4].

Insurance and safeguards C5 · weight 10%

Insufficient evidence

Pricing transparency C6 · weight 5%

40 out of 100

No fees, commission terms, free-quote statement or VAT position are published ^[1] ^[2].

Website and service information C7 · weight 5%

85 out of 100

The site sets out tipper, haulage, fleet, goods-in-transit and liability cover with named teams ^[1] ^[3], gives phone, email and a contact form ^[2], and tells its Telford story ^[3].

Evidence

Every fact held for this provider, with its source and check date.
Fact	Value	Source	Read
Limited company since	2005	Source companies-house	4 September 2026

Industry qualifications

Sourced from the issuing registers, the business's own website and platforms such as Checkatrade and Which? Trusted Traders, on the date shown.

Financial Conduct AuthoritySourcedchecked 4 September 2026. Reference Registered Number: 447730.
British Insurance Brokers' AssociationSourcedchecked 4 September 2026

Strengths

You get a haulage-only specialist covering tippers, mixers, skip lorries, refrigerated and livestock carriers plus goods in transit and excess cover ^[1].
The site names the people behind the phones across truck, fleet, renewals and claims teams ^[3].
BIBA membership sits alongside stated FCA authorisation on the firm's own site ^[1] ^[2].

Limitations

The Google rating is 3.6 out of 5 from 17 reviews, seen 4 September 2026 ^[5].
No fees, commission terms or VAT position are published ^[1] ^[2].

Response from the business

This business has not sent a response yet. Any response they send will appear here.

Verified customer reviews

Reviews from customers who showed us their invoice.

No verified reviews yet for this business.

Review this business

Tell other readers about work you paid for, and send a copy of the invoice so the editor can confirm the job took place.

Your name

We publish your first name and last initial only, for example Sarah M.

Your email address

We keep your email address private and use it to contact you about your review.

Your rating

Choose between 1 and 5, where 5 means the work fully met your expectations.

Work done

Describe the job in a few words, for example Consumer unit replacement.

Month the work finished

Pick the month and year the work was completed, within the last three years.

Your review

Describe the work, how it went, and anything other readers should check before booking.

Copy of your invoice

Attach a PDF or photo of the invoice for this job so the editor can confirm the work; only the editor sees it.

Questions about Compare HGV Insurance

Is Compare HGV Insurance any good?

On the evidence, yes for haulage and nothing else: it sits ninth in our Telford insurance brokers table, with a haulage-only range from tippers to fleets and named truck, fleet and claims teams. The review score trails the table, so read the full page and its sources. Ask for a like-for-like fleet quote.

Is Compare HGV Insurance FCA registered?

FCA authorisation under a printed registered number is stated on the firm's own contact page, alongside BIBA membership. Check the name and number match on the FCA register before you share fleet detail. Ask for both references with your quote. The trading name sits under a wider insurance operator, so match that operator name on the register too.

What does Compare HGV Insurance charge?

The site publishes no fees, commission terms or VAT position, so the written quote does the talking. Ask what the broker earns on your policy and whether any fee adds VAT. Get the answers in writing before cover starts on any fleet policy. Nothing on the site suggests a free-quote promise, so confirm the quote route first.

Where does Compare HGV Insurance work?

The firm works from Telford, describing itself as born and bred in the town, and serves hauliers running in and around it. Send your operating centre postcode with vehicle numbers to confirm you are covered. Ask who handles renewals and claims out of hours. The Stafford Park base keeps the team close to the town's industrial estates.

How is Compare HGV Insurance ranked?

It ranks ninth of the ten brokers in our September round, carried by its niche range and stated memberships. The table's weakest review score holds it back. Read the full review, then compare its quote with one general commercial broker. Its haulage-only range is unmatched anywhere else in the table.

How do I get a quote from Compare HGV Insurance?

Start through the phone or contact form on the firm's site with the operating centre postcode and vehicle numbers ready. Say whether the need is a single truck, a mixed fleet or goods in transit so the enquiry lands with the right team. Named people stand behind each of the teams.

What do customers say about Compare HGV Insurance?

Fewer than twenty Google reviews average in the middle of the scale — the weakest score in the top ten. That middling record stands out in a strong round for customer voices. The count leaves plenty of room for the record to move as new reviews land. Read a spread of the reviews before deciding.

How does Compare HGV Insurance compare with the others in this round?

It ranks ninth of the ten, carried by a haulage-only range no general broker matches. The review score trails the table, which is what holds it back. Our view is that hauliers gain more from its trade fluency than they lose on polish. General brokers above it offer wider cover but thinner trade knowledge.

Others assessed for this trade

Paul Humphreys Credit Insurance Services66.9 / 100Ranked 1. Best for spotless reviews and a single-trade credit focus.
Q Financial Services66.3 / 100Ranked 2. Best for wellington broker covering protection and commercial finance.
Fiveways Insurance66.2 / 100Ranked 3. Best for newport broker for business and personal cover since 1967.
Pensionlite65.9 / 100Ranked 4. Best for chartered advice house for protection alongside pensions.

Sources

Compare HGV homepage — products, BIBA membership and Telford roots Retrieved 4 September 2026.
Compare HGV contact page — phone, email, form and authorisation Retrieved 4 September 2026.
Compare HGV about page — heritage, teams and Telford base Retrieved 4 September 2026.
Companies House — ONE SURE INSURANCE LIMITED overview (05649077) Retrieved 4 September 2026.
Google Maps listing — Compare HGV Insurance, Telford Retrieved 4 September 2026.

Is this your business?

Ask us to correct a fact, claim the listing, or send a response for publication alongside the assessment.

Suggest a correction Claim this listing Send a response